Understanding Pregnancy Stress: What You Need to Know
Written on
Pregnancy can provoke a wide range of emotions, from joy to anxiety, and many agree that it often comes with its fair share of stress. This stress is understandable; after all, creating and nurturing a new life is a monumental task that can naturally lead to feelings of anxiety.
Recently, those expecting or planning a pregnancy may have felt even more pressure due to alarming headlines suggesting that stress during pregnancy could lead to mental health issues in children later in life. Reports have claimed that pregnant individuals experiencing stress are “three times” more likely to have children with personality disorders, and that this risk could escalate to nearly “ten times” with higher stress levels.
Fortunately, the reality is less alarming than portrayed.
Worrying excessively about stress is unnecessary; it is unlikely to result in mental health issues for your children.
Scientific Statements
The source of these concerns stems from a retrospective cohort study conducted on mothers who reported their mental health during pregnancy in the 1970s. Researchers tracked the health of their children four decades later, categorizing the pregnancies into three levels of stress: none, some, and high, while assessing the children’s mental health regarding personality disorders.
The findings were startling — children born to mothers who reported stress during pregnancy had a threefold increase in the likelihood of being diagnosed with personality disorders years later. This figure rose even higher for certain conditions, with stress correlating to a thirteenfold increase in anxiety disorders.
Such findings led to sensational headlines warning against stress during pregnancy, implying that it could lead to inevitable suffering for the child. However, the scientific evidence was not as dire as the media suggested.
Scientific Shenanigans
It is essential to recognize that this was observational research. Observational studies can complicate causal inferences due to the multifaceted nature of health determinants. Even after accounting for various factors, societal influences often play a significant role in observed outcomes.
In this instance, the researchers only considered a limited number of variables, ignoring many significant factors that could affect mental health, such as income and social status. It is plausible that higher-income women may have less stressful pregnancies and healthier children due to better access to healthcare.
The limited control over these variables raises questions about the study's findings. The sample size included 3,626 mother-child pairs, yet there were only 40 cases of personality disorders, complicating statistical modeling.
Logistic regression models, used in the study, can yield unreliable results with such a small number of outcomes. Introducing more variables, like socio-economic status, could further distort the findings, making it challenging to draw definitive conclusions.
Additionally, the absolute risk increase reported was minimal. While headlines highlighted the “triple risk,” the actual risk difference was only around 1% between stressed and non-stressed mothers. For example, if 100 mothers experienced stress during pregnancy, one additional child might be diagnosed with a personality disorder compared to 100 mothers who were stress-free.
This perspective significantly diminishes the fear instilled by the media.
Ridiculous Reporting
In conclusion, the implications of this study are limited. For healthcare providers, it may be beneficial to consider stress levels during check-ups, as the study suggests. However, most practitioners likely already do so.
For anyone who is pregnant or planning to be, the findings may not hold much weight. Although there could be a slight increase in risk associated with stress, the statistical uncertainties make it difficult to ascertain its significance. Furthermore, the study did not establish causation, suggesting that factors like financial stability could be more influential on children's mental health than stress alone.
Stress during pregnancy is not ideal, but it is often unavoidable. The notion that it inevitably harms the baby is not only unhelpful but also somewhat ludicrous.
If concerns arise regarding your or your baby's health, consult a healthcare professional, preferably an obstetrician.
Just remember, there’s no need to overly stress about stress; it’s unlikely to negatively impact your baby after all.
If you enjoyed this content, consider following me on Medium, Twitter, or Facebook!
You can now listen to Gid on the Sensationalist Science podcast for your weekly dose of scientific insights and media analysis.