Understanding Why Business Strategies Often Fall Short
Written on
In the realm of business, models and strategies frequently encounter failure, and understanding this phenomenon is essential.
During a power outage in 2018, while working on a project, I was forced into silence, a rare opportunity for focused thought. As I sat in my quiet home, devoid of background noise, I opened Photoshop to create a graphic for my website, only to be greeted by a message stating it could not authenticate without an internet connection.
Unlike Photoshop, I could easily enjoy gaming in offline mode with Minecraft, as it allows access without needing to connect to the internet. I also appreciate using StackEdit, which offers offline functionality, enabling continuous work without interruptions. In stark contrast, Photoshop wouldn’t even load before shutting down, leaving me frustrated despite paying $34.99 monthly for the suite.
Music production has its challenges too, but software like Ableton Live and Splice, which use internet authentication, still function offline. Meanwhile, my experience with Photoshop, which I owned, was disappointing as the older versions also failed to run despite my annual payment.
Eventually, I decided to uninstall Photoshop and the entire Creative Cloud suite, even obtaining refunds for the months I didn’t utilize the software—an act driven by my frugality.
Humor aside, the SaaS model proved to be a failure for me with Photoshop.
A Closer Look at Business Models
In business, it's not uncommon to borrow techniques from one industry to apply them in another, a practice that can be risky yet rewarding. Business relies on mastering various tools and techniques, a skill honed by humanity over centuries. Unlike Neanderthals, who relied on short-range weaponry, early humans advanced with long-range tools, showcasing an innate ability to learn and adapt.
This process-oriented approach allows for reflection and optimization, making business models a critical part of the equation. Successful businesses refine their processes and adopt techniques from competitors to enhance efficiency.
The Rise and Fall of Giants
We've witnessed companies adopting models from successful competitors, often to their detriment. Take SnapChat Stories, which some thought would spell doom for SnapChat as Instagram integrated similar features.
To succeed in business, one must prepare for competition that may refine or enhance flagship products. Consider the case of Vine, which offered a unique 6-second video format. Instagram capitalized on this by incorporating video features, leading to Vine’s decline.
Vine's downfall was not due to a lack of innovation but rather a failure to adapt to user convenience. Business models can be as fragile as glass; without a solid foundation and ecosystem, they risk being overshadowed by competitors.
Vine allowed users to post and engage with 6-second clips, but Instagram provided a more comprehensive experience with messaging, comments, and a pre-existing user base. When Instagram added video capabilities within six months of Vine’s success, the latter struggled to keep pace.
Instagram's adaptability ensured its survival, especially after borrowing features like Stories from SnapChat, further solidifying its lead in the market.
Understanding Business Model Failures
On September 25, 1926, the Ford Motor Company implemented a 40-hour work week, leading to increased productivity as employees enjoyed more personal time. However, with modern distractions like screens and social media disrupting sleep, this model faces challenges.
As fatigue becomes a common complaint among workers, there may be calls to reduce hours to boost productivity. Yet, this overlooks the fact that exhaustion often stems from factors unrelated to job demands.
Today's businesses operate within ecosystems that differ significantly from those of the past, indicating that the traditional business model may be flawed.
The core issue lies in the composition fallacy—the notion that simply transferring components from one successful model to another guarantees success. Just as wheels cannot propel a canoe, borrowing elements without context does not ensure functionality.
In conclusion, adapting to the current landscape is crucial for business survival, and a holistic approach is necessary for long-term success.